Skip to main content

Electrical Power Equipment • Global Sourcing • Project Supply

Send your requirement

Specifying LED Luminaires: Output, Optics, Environment and Controls

How to read and specify LED luminaire data: flux vs efficacy, optics, glare, colour, IP/IK, surge, Lx/By lifetime claims and controls.

LED luminaire datasheets are full of impressive numbers, but many of them describe something other than the luminaire. A headline efficacy may belong to the LED chip at a laboratory temperature. A lifetime quoted as a bare number of hours may say nothing about how much light remains or how many units have failed by then. A glare value may only hold in one standard room. When luminaires from different sources are compared on these figures, the comparison can be meaningless. Specifying well means asking for the luminaire’s own performance, measured and declared in a consistent way, and reading each claim with its conditions attached.

This article answers the question: which data define whether an LED luminaire is suitable for a project, how should each parameter be read, and how can datasheet claims be compared on a fair basis?

This article is general selection guidance. It explains how to specify and evaluate luminaires and quotes no manufacturer’s data.

Key takeaways

  • Specify luminaire performance, not LED chip performance. Optical, thermal and driver losses mean a luminaire’s flux and efficacy are always lower than those of the LEDs inside it.
  • Luminous flux (lm) is how much light the luminaire emits. Efficacy (lm/W) is flux divided by the luminaire’s input power. A high efficacy does not tell you whether the luminaire produces enough light, or puts it in the right place.
  • Optics decide where the light goes. Ask for the luminous intensity distribution and a photometric file, not just a beam angle.
  • Glare (UGR for interiors) depends on the installation, not only the luminaire. A datasheet UGR value is a table value under standard conditions.
  • Colour quality needs CCT, CRI (and R9 where it matters) and colour consistency, both initially and over life.
  • Environmental suitability includes IP (IEC 60529), IK (IEC 62262), the performance ambient temperature tq as distinct from the safety ambient ta, and surge withstand.
  • Lifetime claims are meaningful only in the LxBy form with an ambient temperature, plus a separate abrupt-failure figure. “L80B10 at [rated hours], tq [stated temperature]” is a claim. A bare number of hours is not.
  • Controls (DALI, 1–10 V, sensors) are part of the specification, as are driver inrush current and power quality.

Why luminaire specification goes wrong

Three habits cause most problems:

  • Comparing different objects. One offer quotes the LED package, another the module, a third the complete luminaire.
  • Comparing without conditions. Flux or lifetime declared at different ambient temperatures are not comparable.
  • Buying on a single headline figure, usually efficacy or price per lumen, while ignoring distribution, glare, colour and durability.

The remedy is to specify what the project needs as luminaire-level performance under stated conditions, and to ask for the evidence.

From chip to luminaire: which level a number describes

Which level does a datasheet figure describe? Conceptual diagram of four levels of an LED luminaire, left to right. Level 1, LED package: the light-emitting device, with data measured at a fixed test temperature and current; typical quoted figures are LED efficacy and LED lumen-maintenance data. Level 2, LED module: LEDs on a board, sometimes with optics or electronics, with performance covered by IEC 62717; typical figures are module flux, life and photometric code. Level 3, control gear or driver: converts mains to LED current and determines efficiency, surge withstand and life, with safety covered by the IEC 61347 series; typical figures are driver efficiency, power factor, surge withstand and life. Level 4, luminaire: housing, heat sink, optics, modules, driver and connections, with performance covered by IEC 62722-2-1 and safety by IEC 60598-1; typical figures are rated luminaire flux, luminaire efficacy, lifetime in LxBy form and the performance ambient temperature tq. Level 4 is highlighted with the label “specify here”. Arrows between the levels show thermal losses because LEDs run hotter in use, optical losses in lenses, diffusers and reflectors, and driver conversion losses. A note states that luminaire flux and efficacy are always lower than the figures for the LEDs inside it. Which level does a datasheet figure describe? From LED package to complete luminaire. Specify luminaire-level performance. SPECIFY HERE LEVEL 1 LED package Light-emitting device Data at fixed test temperature and current Manufacturer test data LEVEL 2 LED module LEDs on a board, sometimes with optics or electronics Performance: IEC 62717 LEVEL 3 Control gear (driver) Converts mains to LED current; sets efficiency, surge, life Safety: IEC 61347 series LEVEL 4 Luminaire Housing, heat sink, optics, module(s), driver, connections Perf.: IEC 62722-2-1 Safety: IEC 60598-1 Thermal LEDs run hotter in use Optical lens, diffuser, reflector Driver conversion losses Figures often quoted at each level LED efficacy (lm/W) LED lumen-maintenance data Module flux and life photometric code Driver efficiency, PF, surge withstand, life Rated luminaire flux, luminaire efficacy, LxBy, tq Luminaire flux and efficacy are always lower than the figures for the LEDs inside it. Generic, conceptual levels. No product data. IEC 62717 · IEC 62722-2-1 · IEC 60598-1
Four levels of an LED luminaire, from LED package to complete luminaire, showing where losses occur and which level each figure describes.

An LED luminaire is built in layers:

  1. LED package (often called the chip). The light-emitting device. Its data, such as flux, efficacy and lumen maintenance test data, are measured under controlled conditions, often at a fixed temperature and drive current.
  2. LED module. LEDs mounted on a board, sometimes with optics or electronics. Performance requirements for LED modules for general lighting are covered by IEC 62717.
  3. Control gear (driver). Converts the mains supply to the DC current the LEDs need. Its efficiency, power factor, surge withstand and lifetime affect the luminaire directly.
  4. Luminaire. The complete product: housing, heat sink, optics, module(s), driver and connections. Performance requirements for LED luminaires are covered by IEC 62722-2-1 (with the general requirements in IEC 62722-1). Safety requirements are covered by IEC 60598-1 and its particular parts.

Between the LED and the luminaire output, light is lost in the optics and diffuser, the LEDs run hotter than in the lab and emit less, and the driver consumes power. The luminaire’s flux and efficacy are therefore always lower than the figures for the LEDs inside it. Only luminaire-level figures belong in a specification.

IEC 62722-2-1 lists the performance information a luminaire manufacturer should provide, including rated input power, rated luminous flux, rated luminous efficacy, chromaticity and colour rendering, the ambient performance temperature, and rated life data. Luminaire efficacy is the measured initial luminous flux divided by the measured initial input power of the luminaire.

Output: luminous flux and efficacy

  • Luminous flux (lumen, lm) is the total visible light emitted by the luminaire. It determines how much light is available to the space. It does not determine where the light goes.
  • Luminous efficacy (lm/W) is flux divided by electrical input power. It measures energy efficiency. A luminaire with high efficacy but too little flux, or the wrong distribution, is still the wrong luminaire.

How much flux a project needs is not chosen from a catalogue. It comes from a lighting calculation: the required maintained illuminance for each task area, the room or site geometry, surface reflectances, the luminaire’s intensity distribution, and a maintenance factor that allows for lumen depreciation and dirt. Lighting design is done by a lighting designer or engineer using the luminaire’s photometric data. The specification then fixes the luminaire performance that makes that design work.

Points to check:

  • Is the flux rated luminaire flux (initial, complete luminaire) or an LED or module value?
  • At what ambient temperature is it stated? (See tq below.)
  • What tolerance applies between rated and measured values?
  • Is the input power the total luminaire power, including the driver?

Optics: where the light goes

The luminous intensity distribution shows how much light the luminaire emits in each direction. It is usually drawn as a polar curve in one or more planes, and supplied as a photometric data file. EULUMDAT (.ldt) and IES LM-63 (.ies) formats are both widely used.

Same light, different direction: reading a polar intensity curve Two illustrative polar intensity diagrams for downward-facing luminaires, each normalised to its own peak, not product data. Each has semicircular rings at 25, 50, 75 and 100 percent of peak intensity and radial lines at 0, 30, 60 and 90 degrees from straight down. Left, a narrow distribution whose intensity falls to 50 percent of peak at 30 degrees either side of straight down, giving a beam angle of 60 degrees (illustrative only), suited to concentrating light, for example in tall spaces. Right, a wide distribution whose intensity falls to 50 percent at 60 degrees either side, giving a beam angle of 120 degrees (illustrative only), suited to spreading light, for example at lower mounting heights. Red dots mark the 50 percent points that define the beam angle. A note advises asking for the photometric file rather than only the beam angle. Same light, different direction: reading a polar intensity curve Illustrative distributions, each normalised to its own peak. Not product data. Narrow distribution 0° 30° 60° 90° 30° 60° 90° 25% 50% 75% 100% 60° Beam angle 60° (illustrative only, not product data) Concentrated: e.g. tall spaces Wide distribution 0° 30° 60° 90° 30° 60° 90° 25% 50% 75% 100% 120° Beam angle 120° (illustrative only, not product data) Spread: e.g. lower mounting heights Beam angle = angle between the directions where intensity falls to 50% of its peak (red dots). Ask for the photometric file (.ldt / .ies), not only the beam angle. Cosine-generated shapes; illustrative only, not product data
Schematic polar curves for a narrow and a wide distribution; beam angle read at 50% of peak. Illustrative only, not product data.

Key concepts:

  • Beam angle: commonly the angle between the two directions where the intensity falls to 50% of its peak value. Two luminaires with the same flux and different beam angles produce very different illuminance patterns.
  • Symmetric and asymmetric distributions: high-bay luminaires for tall industrial spaces often use narrower beams, low ceilings wider ones. Area, façade and road lighting use asymmetric optics to direct light forward and limit spill and upward light.
  • Cut-off and upward light matter outdoors, both for glare and for limiting light pollution, where local rules apply.

For a specification, the beam angle alone is not enough. Ask for the photometric file so the lighting calculation can be checked with the actual luminaire.

Glare

Glare reduces visual comfort and can impair performance. For indoor lighting, the usual metric is the Unified Glare Rating (UGR), defined by CIE 117 and presented as luminaire tables using the method of CIE 190. The indoor workplace lighting standard ISO/CIE 8995-1 sets limiting UGR values for tasks and activities. These values must also be confirmed against any national or regional lighting standard that applies, such as EN 12464-1 in Europe.

How to read UGR claims:

  • UGR depends on the installation: room dimensions, luminaire layout, mounting height, surface reflectances and the observer’s position. It is not an intrinsic property of the luminaire alone.
  • A datasheet UGR value normally comes from a standard table under defined conditions. It is a useful comparison but does not guarantee the result in every room.
  • For important spaces, verify UGR in the lighting calculation for the actual layout.

Outdoor and road lighting use different glare metrics. These are covered in a separate Engineering Insights article on street and area lighting.

Colour: CCT, CRI and consistency

  • Correlated colour temperature (CCT, kelvin) describes whether white light appears warm (lower K) or cool (higher K). The choice depends on the application and on user preferences. Industrial and infrastructure projects commonly use neutral to cool white. Requirements can vary by application and by country.
  • Colour rendering index (CRI, Ra) describes how faithfully colours appear under the light compared with a reference source, on a scale up to 100. Where colour discrimination matters, also ask for R9 (saturated red), which the general Ra does not include.
  • Colour consistency describes how closely luminaires match each other and how stable their colour remains over life. It is often expressed in MacAdam ellipse steps (SDCM): a smaller number means a tighter match. Ask for both initial and maintained values.

IEC 62717 and IEC 62722-2-1 use a compact photometric code that combines colour rendering, CCT, colour consistency and lumen maintenance information in one string. Where a datasheet quotes one, ask for the individual values as well, so they can be checked one by one.

Environmental suitability

Ingress protection (IP) and impact protection (IK)

  • IP code (IEC 60529): protection against solid objects and dust (first digit) and water (second digit). For example, IP65 means dust-tight and protected against water jets. Choose the IP code from the actual exposure: indoor dry, wash-down, outdoor rain, dust-laden industrial air.
  • IK code (IEC 62262): protection of the enclosure against mechanical impact, from IK00 to IK10, with IK11 added by the 2021 amendment. Specify a higher IK code where luminaires are within reach or exposed to vandalism or impacts, such as low mounting heights, sports halls or public areas.

IP and IK are separate properties. One does not imply the other.

Ambient temperature: tq is not ta

Two temperatures appear on luminaire documentation and are easily confused:

  • ta: rated maximum ambient temperature for safety. Under IEC 60598-1, it is the highest ambient temperature at which the luminaire can be operated safely. It is a safety limit.
  • tq: rated ambient performance temperature. Under IEC 62722-2-1, it is the ambient temperature at which the declared performance (flux, efficacy, lifetime) applies.

A luminaire’s ta may be well above the tq at which its flux and lifetime figures are declared, so a luminaire can be safe at a temperature where its declared performance no longer applies. At higher ambient temperatures the LEDs and driver run hotter, so flux and life are usually lower than the declared values. Specify the actual ambient temperature at the luminaire, for example under a hot warehouse roof, inside a process hall or in a hot climate, and ask for performance data at that temperature.

Surge withstand and electrical environment

Outdoor and industrial luminaires are exposed to transient overvoltages from lightning and switching. LED drivers have a declared surge withstand, usually stated separately for differential mode (line to neutral) and common mode (line or neutral to earth). It is tested using the method of IEC 61000-4-5. Where the exposure exceeds the driver’s capability, typically in outdoor lighting on long supply runs, additional surge protective devices in the luminaire or the supply are specified. The required level depends on the installation and its exposure. It is part of the electrical design, not a fixed number. Where supply-side surge protective devices usually sit in the LV system, and how lighting final circuits are fed from the boards above them, is shown in LV Distribution Explained: From Transformer to Final Circuit.

Also consider:

  • Corrosive, chemical or salt atmospheres: housing material, coatings and gasket compatibility.
  • Vibration: for example near heavy machinery or on bridges.
  • Hazardous (explosive) atmospheres: these require equipment certified for the zone. That topic lies outside this article.

Lifetime claims: reading Lx/By critically

LEDs rarely fail suddenly. Their light output declines gradually. Lifetime is therefore expressed as the time until the light output has fallen to a stated fraction, combined with a statement about how many units are allowed to have fallen below it.

Reading an LED lifetime claim Decoder for an LED lifetime claim of the form “L80 B10 at rated hours, at tq”, with no product values. L80 means the time at which luminous flux has fallen to 80 percent of its initial value. B10 means at most 10 percent of operating units are below that threshold. The rated hours are the operating time at which this condition is declared. tq is the ambient temperature at which the performance applies. A conceptual chart plots luminous flux from 100 to 60 percent against operating hours: a dashed red line marks the 80 percent threshold; a blue curve for the median unit is still above 80 percent at the rated hours, while a black curve for the lowest 10 percent of units reaches 80 percent exactly at the rated hours, marked as the point where L80B10 is reached. A note says units that have stopped operating are counted separately as the abrupt failure value. A checklist states that a bare hours figure leaves open the flux threshold, the share of units, the ambient temperature, whether it describes the luminaire or only the LED package, abrupt failures and driver life, and whether the figure was measured or extrapolated and how far. When only Lx is given, it means LxB50, the median. Reading an LED lifetime claim Example claim decoded, with a conceptual flux-maintenance chart. Illustrative; not product data. L80 B10 · [rated hours] · tq [°C] L80: flux threshold Time at which flux has fallen to 80% of its initial value B10: share of units At most 10% of operating units are below that threshold [rated hours]: the time Operating hours at which the L80 B10 condition is declared tq: conditions Ambient temperature at which the performance applies 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% Luminous flux (% of initial) Operating hours (conceptual) rated hours 80% threshold (L80) L80B10 reached median unit (B50) lowest 10% of units (B10) Shapes are conceptual. Units that have stopped operating are counted separately (AFV). A bare hours figure leaves open: Which flux threshold? (Lx) What share of units? (By) At what ambient temperature? (tq) Luminaire, or LED package only? Abrupt failures and driver life? (AFV) Measured, or extrapolated, and how far? Example claim; definitions per IEC 62717 / IEC 62722-2-1 terms. Lx alone = LxB50 (median)
How to read an LED lifetime claim of the form “L80B10 at [rated hours], tq [temperature]”, and what a bare hours figure leaves unanswered.

In the terms used by IEC 62717 and IEC 62722-2-1:

  • Lx: the time at which the luminous flux has fallen to x% of its initial value. For example, L80 means 80% of initial flux remains.
  • By: the proportion of units, y%, that are allowed to have fallen below the Lx threshold at that time. B10 means at most 10% of units are below 80% flux. B50 means half of them are.
  • Rated median useful life (Lx): when only Lx is given, it conventionally means LxB50, the median.
  • Gradual vs abrupt failure: LxBy describes gradual flux loss in luminaires that are still operating. Units that have stopped working (abrupt failure, for example of an LED or the driver) are reported separately, as an abrupt failure value (AFV).

How to read a claim critically:

  1. Is it Lx alone, or LxBy? At the same rated hours, an “L70” claim (= L70B50) is far less demanding than an “L80B10” claim.
  2. At what ambient temperature (tq)? A lifetime declared at a lower tq may not hold at the higher ambient temperature of the actual site.
  3. Luminaire or LED? LED package test data, such as lumen maintenance testing to IES LM-80 with projection to IES TM-21 (both North American methods widely quoted internationally), describe the LED package, not the complete luminaire. They are an input to a luminaire claim, not a substitute for one.
  4. How far has it been extrapolated? Lifetimes of tens of thousands of hours are projected from much shorter tests. Recognised methods limit how far a projection may extend beyond the test duration. Ask how the figure was derived.
  5. What about the driver and abrupt failures? The driver often limits the luminaire’s real life. Ask for the AFV or the driver’s rated life at the relevant case temperature.
  6. What does the warranty cover? A warranty period is a commercial term, not a measured lifetime.

The lifetime figure also links back to design: the maintenance factor used in the lighting calculation should be consistent with the flux the luminaire is expected to deliver at the end of the planned maintenance period.

Controls

Controls determine how much energy is actually saved and how flexibly the lighting can be used:

  • Switching only: simplest, with no dimming.
  • 1–10 V dimming: analogue, widely used, with limited feedback.
  • DALI (IEC 62386 series): a digital, addressable interface. Each driver can be addressed, dimmed, grouped and monitored, including fault reporting. IEC 62386-101 and -102 cover the system and control-gear requirements. Further parts cover particular device types, for example colour control. Product interoperability programmes, such as DALI-2 certification, are run by the DALI Alliance.
  • Sensors: presence and absence detection, and daylight-linked dimming. Effective in intermittently used spaces such as warehouses, corridors and plant rooms.
  • Constant light output (CLO): the driver starts below full power and increases output over time to compensate for lumen depreciation. It saves energy early in life, and the end-of-life power must be accounted for.
  • Wireless and networked controls are increasingly common. Check protocol, interoperability and cybersecurity requirements.
  • Emergency lighting may be integrated into luminaires (self-contained) or supplied from a central system, under the relevant particular part of IEC 60598 and national rules.

Electrical points that affect the installation:

  • Inrush current. LED drivers draw a short, high inrush current when switched on. It limits how many drivers can be connected to one miniature circuit-breaker without nuisance tripping. Manufacturers usually state the maximum number of drivers per breaker type and rating. See Choosing LV Circuit Breakers.
  • Power factor and harmonics. At low dimming levels, power factor and harmonic current can worsen. Check driver data across the dimming range.
  • Supply on backup power. If lighting is supplied from a generator or UPS, its inrush and harmonic behaviour form part of that system’s load (see How Generators, UPS and ATS Work Together).

How to read a luminaire datasheet

How to read a luminaire datasheet Annotated generic luminaire datasheet with field labels and empty value slots, containing no product or performance values. Twelve numbered fields each have a callout. 1, luminous flux in lumens: rated luminaire flux, initial, with tq and tolerance stated, not LED or module flux. 2, input power in watts: total luminaire input power including the driver, at the same operating point as the flux. 3, efficacy in lumens per watt: luminaire flux divided by luminaire input power; LED efficacy is not luminaire efficacy. 4, optical distribution: a photometric file for the exact variant; beam angle alone is not enough. 5, glare, UGR: a standard-table value and its conditions, to be verified for the real room in the lighting calculation. 6, CCT in kelvin and CRI: CCT chosen for the application and CRI, with R9, for the task, plus colour consistency initial and maintained. 7, lifetime: both x and y of LxBy, at luminaire level and a stated tq, with the abrupt failure value; a bare hours figure is not a lifetime claim. 8, ambient ta and tq: ta is a safety limit, tq a performance condition; performance is needed at the real site ambient. 9, IP and IK codes matched to exposure; IP does not imply impact resistance. 10, driver surge withstand in differential and common mode and inrush current per circuit-breaker; outdoor runs may need an additional surge protective device. 11, controls: interface, dimming range, constant light output and emergency option, compatible with the control system. 12, standards declared: safety to IEC 60598-1 and the relevant part 2, performance to IEC 62722-2-1; regional marks are not universal. Fields 1, 2, 3 and 7 are tagged “luminaire” to show the level the value must describe. How to read a luminaire datasheet Generic datasheet layout with field labels only. Each callout says what the value must describe and what to check. No product data. LUMINAIRE DATASHEET (generic) Luminous flux LUMINAIRE [ lm ] 1 1 Rated luminaire flux, initial; tq and tolerance stated Not LED or module flux Input power LUMINAIRE [ W ] 2 2 Total luminaire input power, incl. driver Same operating point as the flux Efficacy LUMINAIRE [ lm/W ] 3 3 Luminaire flux ÷ luminaire input power “LED efficacy” is not luminaire efficacy Optical distribution [ file / beam ] 4 4 Photometric file (.ldt / .ies) for the exact variant Beam angle alone is not enough Glare (UGR) [ table value ] 5 5 Standard-table value and its conditions Verify for the real room in the calculation CCT / CRI [ K ] / [ Ra ] 6 6 CCT for the application; CRI (and R9) for the task Ask for colour consistency, initial and maintained Lifetime LUMINAIRE [ LxBy @ h, tq ] 7 7 Both x and y, luminaire-level, at a stated tq; AFV A bare hours figure is not a lifetime claim Ambient ta / tq [ °C ] / [ °C ] 8 8 ta = safety limit; tq = performance condition Need performance at the real site ambient IP / IK [ IP ] / [ IK ] 9 9 Both codes, matched to exposure IP does not imply impact resistance (IK) Driver: surge, inrush [ kV ] / [ A ] 10 10 Surge: differential and common mode; inrush per MCB Outdoor runs may need an additional SPD Controls [ interface ] 11 11 Interface, dimming range, CLO, emergency option Check compatibility with the control system Standards declared [ IEC … ] 12 12 Safety IEC 60598-1 + part 2; performance IEC 62722-2-1 Regional marks are not universal Field layout only. Values come from the specific product’s declared data. Generic field layout; no product, manufacturer or performance values. IEC 62722-2-1 · IEC 60598-1 · IEC 60529 · IEC 62262
Annotated generic datasheet: each field, the level it must describe, and what to check. Field labels only; no product data.

A datasheet is easier to judge when each figure is checked against three questions: which level does it describe (LED, module, driver or luminaire), under which conditions (temperature, drive current, tolerance), and is the evidence available (a test report, a photometric file, a declaration against the relevant IEC performance standard)? The decoder below lists the fields a luminaire datasheet should contain and what to check in each. It contains no values, because the values belong to a specific product.

Datasheet fieldWhat it should stateWhat to check
Luminous flux (lm)Rated luminaire flux, initialLuminaire, not LED or module; tq and tolerance stated
Input power (W)Total luminaire input powerIncludes driver losses; at the same operating point as the flux
Efficacy (lm/W)Rated luminaire efficacyEquals luminaire flux ÷ luminaire input power; not “LED efficacy”
Optical distributionIntensity distribution, beam angle, optic typePhotometric file (.ldt / .ies) supplied for the exact variant offered
Glare (UGR)UGR table value and the table conditionsStandard-table value only; verify in the project calculation
ColourCCT (K), CRI (Ra), R9 if relevant, colour consistencyInitial and maintained values; consistency in MacAdam steps
LifetimeLxBy at [rated hours], tq, AFVBoth x and y given; luminaire-level; ambient stated; abrupt failures separate
Ambientta (safety) and tq (performance)Performance data available at the real site ambient
ProtectionIP code, IK codeBoth codes, matched to exposure; IP does not imply IK
Driver and surgeDriver type, surge withstand (differential and common mode), inrush currentAdequate for the installation; drivers per MCB stated
ControlsInterface (switching, 1–10 V, DALI), dimming range, CLO, emergency optionCompatible with the control system; behaviour across the dimming range
ComplianceSafety and performance standards declaredIEC 60598-1 and relevant part 2; performance per IEC 62722-2-1; regional requirements of the destination market

A comparison framework: trade-offs, not headline numbers

When two luminaire options are being compared, they rarely differ in only one parameter. The framework below shows common trade-offs qualitatively. Each one should be resolved with luminaire-level data for the actual options and the project’s lighting calculation, not by choosing the larger number on a datasheet.

ChoiceWhat it may gainWhat it may cost or leave openHow to decide
Higher-efficacy option vs wider-optic optionHigher efficacy: less input power for the same fluxA narrower or less suitable distribution can require more luminaires or give poorer uniformity, cancelling the energy gainCompare installed power and uniformity in the lighting calculation, using both photometric files
Higher flux per luminaire vs more luminaires of lower fluxFewer luminaires, fewer mounting pointsHigher glare risk and poorer uniformity at the same mounting heightCheck UGR (indoors) and uniformity for the actual layout
Cooler CCT vs warmer CCTCooler CCT options sometimes declare slightly higher efficacyVisual comfort and application suitability. CCT is an application choice, not an efficiency settingChoose the CCT for the application first, then compare like with like
Higher CRI vs standard CRIBetter colour rendering where colour discrimination mattersOften a lower declared efficacySpecify the CRI (and R9) the task needs. Do not pay in efficacy for rendering the task does not need
Stricter lifetime claim vs longer-hours claimAn LxBy claim with higher x and lower y is more demanding at the same hoursA claim with more hours but a looser x/y, or no tq, may promise lessNormalise: compare the same Lx and By at the same tq, with AFV
Higher IP/IK vs lighter enclosureDurability in dust, water or impact exposurePossible thermal or optical trade-offs; costMatch IP and IK to the real exposure; check performance at tq
Integrated controls (DALI, sensors) vs switching onlyEnergy savings, monitoring, flexibilityCommissioning effort, compatibility, costDecide the control strategy at system level before comparing luminaires
Driver with higher surge withstand vs additional SPDFewer separate componentsMay still be insufficient for exposed outdoor runsTreat surge protection as part of the electrical design

The aim is to ensure that two options are compared on the same basis: luminaire-level values, the same conditions, and the same lighting result. An option that cannot supply luminaire-level data under stated conditions cannot yet be compared at all. The right next step is to ask for that data, not to estimate it.

Specification checklist

The datasheet decoder above doubles as the specification checklist. For an enquiry, state the required value or condition for each field: flux and distribution (from the lighting calculation), glare limit, CCT and CRI, the lifetime claim form and the site ambient at which it must apply, IP and IK, surge and inrush constraints, the control interface, and the compliance evidence expected.

Regional requirements (contextual only). Some markets add their own rules. In the European Union, for example, ecodesign and energy labelling regulations apply to light sources and separate control gear placed on the EU market. These requirements apply only where the regulation is in force. They do not define performance for other destination markets, which may have their own rules.

Common mistakes

  • Specifying or comparing LED chip efficacy or flux instead of luminaire values.
  • Choosing luminaires by efficacy or price per lumen without a lighting calculation using their photometric data.
  • Accepting bare lifetime hours, or LED-package test data, as a luminaire lifetime claim.
  • Confusing ta (safety) with tq (performance), and ignoring the real ambient temperature at the luminaire.
  • Treating a datasheet UGR value as guaranteed for every room.
  • Specifying IP without IK where impact is likely, or the reverse.
  • Leaving surge protection, driver inrush and control interface unspecified until installation.
  • Treating a regional regulatory requirement as a universal technical definition.

Conclusion

A good LED luminaire specification asks for the luminaire’s own, declared performance under stated conditions: rated luminaire flux and efficacy, a photometric file for the lighting calculation, glare and colour data with their conditions, IP, IK and surge withstand matched to the environment, performance at the real ambient temperature (tq rather than ta), and lifetime in LxBy form with abrupt failures stated separately. IEC 60598 covers safety. IEC 62722-2-1 and IEC 62717 provide a consistent framework for declaring luminaire and module performance. Controls and driver behaviour, such as inrush, power factor and dimming, complete the picture. Read this way, datasheets become comparable, and the comparison rests on what the luminaire will actually do in the project.

Related AdepaTrade solutions

AdepaTrade sources indoor, industrial, outdoor, street, solar and emergency lighting, with the poles, controls and supply equipment around them, to project specifications. Lighting & Infrastructure · Low Voltage Distribution & Control

Related articles: LV Distribution Explained: From Transformer to Final Circuit · Choosing LV Circuit Breakers · How Generators, UPS and ATS Work Together

Have a technical question? Talk to our team.

Relevant standards

IEC standards are the primary reference. CIE and ISO/CIE documents cover lighting quality metrics. North American methods (IES) are secondary references where datasheets quote them. Regional regulations are contextual only. Confirm the applicable edition for each project.

StandardWhat it coversWhy it matters
IEC 60598-1: Luminaires, Part 1: General requirements and testsLuminaire safety; rated maximum ambient taConfirms the luminaire is safe at the site ambient; ta is a safety rating, separate from performance data stated at tq
IEC 60598-2 series: Particular requirementsAdditional requirements for luminaire types (e.g. floodlights, road lighting, emergency)Check the part that applies to the type of luminaire being specified
IEC 62722-1: Luminaire performance, Part 1: General requirementsGeneral luminaire performance frameworkThe basis for declaring luminaire performance on a comparable footing
IEC 62722-2-1: Luminaire performance, Part 2-1: Particular requirements for LED luminairesRated flux, efficacy, tq, Lx/By, AFV, photometric codeDefines the datasheet values to request and compare at luminaire level
IEC 62717: LED modules for general lighting, Performance requirementsLED module performance; Lx/By definitionsExplains how lifetime claims are defined, so that different claims can be compared on the same basis
IEC 60529: Degrees of protection provided by enclosures (IP code)Protection against solid objects and water (IP code)Match the IP code to the dust and water exposure at site
IEC 62262 (incl. Amendment 1:2021): Degrees of protection against external mechanical impacts (IK code)Protection against mechanical impact (IK code), including IK11 added by Amendment 1:2021Match the IK code to the impact risk at site
IEC 62386 series: Digital addressable lighting interface (DALI)Digital lighting controlSpecify the DALI parts the control system needs, so that luminaires and controls work together
IEC 61000-4-5: Surge immunity testSurge test method for driversA surge withstand claim is comparable only when the test method and mode (differential and common) are stated
IEC 61347 series: Lamp control gear (safety)Driver safetyConfirms the driver itself meets safety requirements
CIE 117 / CIE 190UGR definition and tabular methodExplains what a datasheet UGR table value means and why it must be checked in the lighting calculation
ISO/CIE 8995-1: Lighting of work places, Part 1: IndoorLimiting UGR and lighting requirements for indoor workplacesSets the requirements the lighting calculation for an indoor workplace must meet
IES LM-80 / IES TM-21 (secondary)LED package lumen maintenance testing and projectionOften quoted on datasheets; they relate to LED packages, so ask how the claim is carried to luminaire level
EU ecodesign / energy labelling for light sources (contextual)EU-market requirements for light sources and separate control gearRelevant only where the product is placed on the EU market